Why This Topic Landed in Japan

Footage said to show migrants overwhelming the Spanish enclave of Ceuta spread as evidence that "multicultural coexistence has failed" and as an image of "what Japan will look like next year," feeding anxiety about accepting foreigners under the banner of a labor shortage. In Ceuta, humanitarian problems following a large 2026 summer influx — people stranded on beaches and streets, moved into makeshift facilities — have been reported by AP and others, but the claim that migrants "turned the whole city into a garbage-strewn slum" overstates a situation that was centered on the beachfront and temporary holding areas. The original video's date, location, and editing remain unclear. Separately, the influencer Yutabon touched off a history argument with the wording that America succeeded not "through" migration but because migrants "took the country over" — pulling in the displacement of Native peoples alongside the immigration story. The dominant tone was strongly against accepting migrants, but it ran next to a smaller, more granular debate about policy design and how to define "success."

Key Reaction Themes

  • Ceuta as failed multiculturalism, projected onto Japan — The largest share read the footage as "Japan's future next year" and warned that admitting foreigners under a labor-shortage banner brings irreversible breakdown of public order.
  • A fight over US history and the meaning of "success" — "America succeeded at invasion; from the natives' view it failed," and warnings not to conflate colonial-era settlement with modern immigration policy.
  • Policy arguments and counterpoints — A smaller group urged copying the strict, managed systems of Singapore or the UAE, insisted that migrants and illegal entrants are different things, and noted that the CEOs of Microsoft, Google, and IBM are all immigrants.
  • A pro-with-limits middle — A few argued Japan has no choice but to admit migrants given the labor shortage, while taking a hard line on illegal entry.

What Japanese Netizens Are Saying

The decline of Spain's Ceuta enclave, read as Japan's future

Footage and articles said to show a rundown Ceuta prompted reactions tying Europe's migration policy to Japan's future.

Sources: 2ch

Comments:

  • "But the Japanese media won't report this."
  • "This is what Japan will look like next year."
  • "The videos from Spain are insane — if you're alone on the street, migrants surround you and take your money and clothes."
  • "This is the world Europeans gladly chose."
  • "In a state like this, you'd lose all interest in watching Barcelona or Lamine Yamal."
  • "Only when people have enough food and clothing do they learn manners."
  • "This is the world Europe wished for when it demanded that diversity be embraced."
  • "It's a weakness of the electoral system — in a few generations they become a majority of the population. Though before that happens, parties like the ones in Germany will probably emerge."
  • "This is the world the LDP wants."
  • "Everyone knows it can't possibly work, so why is it being forced through all over the world?"
  • "Spain's politicians are trash, so the country turning to trash just reflects that."
  • "Places like Kawaguchi are already heading toward something similar."
  • "Sweden, which took in huge numbers of migrants, is completely finished — you're next."
  • "What's happening in Spain is illegal immigration. I'm pro-immigration, but I think we should be strict with illegal immigrants. There's simply not enough labor, so we have no choice but to admit migrants — yes, crime does happen when you do, but if you don't, infrastructure can't be maintained and things get even worse."

Yutabon's "no country succeeded through migration" and the US-history argument

Influencer Yutabon's post set off a debate over whether migration ever made a country succeed, argued through US history.

冒険家ゆたぼん(17)@覚醒モード
冒険家ゆたぼん(17)@覚醒モード
@yutabon_youtube
·

僕が「移民を受け入れて成功した国はないですよね？」とポストしたら「アメリカは移民で成功しました」とか言ってるバカがいました。 だけど、アメリカは『移民で』じゃなくて『移民が』成功した国だろ！アメリカ先住民が虐殺されてるのに、それを『移民で』成功した国と言えるのか？

Reply
Read 483 replies

Comments:

  • "If we're going to admit migrants, we should copy Singapore or the UAE, where it still works reasonably well. Singapore hugely favors its own citizens, has very strong real-estate restrictions, and taxes shoot up just for being a foreigner. Naturally, migrants aren't allowed to get pregnant or give birth, and if you lose your job your whole family is deported. If Japan is going to admit migrants, it should learn from these points."
  • "So by that logic, if the UK and Germany — already in a horrific state right now — turn into Islamic states, that counts as 'succeeding through migration,' right? If being taken over by migrants is success, then sure... terrifying. But if we don't stop it, that's genuinely where we're headed."
  • "The correct phrasing is 'America succeeded at invasion.' As for whether it was a success for the indigenous people — given the sense that the newcomers came without being invited — from the Native Americans' view it wasn't."
  • "Exactly right. In this case, 'ga' and 'de' make a huge difference. Whoever said otherwise must not be fluent in Japanese." [Translator's note: 'migrants ga succeeded' means migrants themselves took the country over, while 'succeeded de migration' means the country succeeded through migration — the particle flips the meaning.]
  • "The United States was founded after WASPs (of British descent) drove out the natives, then took its current shape by accepting immigrants from Italy, Eastern Europe, the Arab world, and China. Twelve million people were screened at Ellis Island by the Statue of Liberty — now a museum. For example, in the early 20th century, at the dawn of the auto industry, it was Arab immigrants working in Detroit's factories."
  • "In America's case, allowing settlement led to: northern Mexico → the Republic of Texas → the Mexican-American War → the cession of northern Mexico → US states; and the Kingdom of Hawaii → the Republic of Hawaii → the Territory of Hawaii → Hawaii, the 50th US state."
  • "The country itself may have succeeded through migration, but the indigenous people were stripped of everything — so America only proves that migration is absolutely a no-go. We have to protect Japanese people's vested interests; those who can defend themselves are fine, but those who can't will just keep being exploited by migrants."
  • "To begin with, 'immigrants' and 'illegal entrants' are completely different things, so unless you weed out the fools who conflate them, you can't even have a discussion."
  • "First, America hasn't succeeded — the fact is that country is just a bunch of disparate pieces forcibly glued together. Thailand seems to have a lot of migrants too, but can we really say that country is doing well?"
  • "It depends on where you set the bar for success, but the current CEOs of Microsoft, Google, and IBM are all immigrants."
  • "There's also an argument that a country that 'had' succeeded through migration was reshaped into its current form by the wealthy."
  • "Migrants invaded and conquered, and now Trump is trying to prevent invasion by shutting out new migrants."