Why This Topic Landed in Japan

Foreigners' legal status and access to public services sits right on top of Japan's ongoing debate over residency and immigration. Anger at covering costly dialysis with public money, and unease at someone seeking a license renewal while lacking residency status, fused with an existing wariness that unlawful stays become a fait accompli. The Supreme Court left open whether excluding foreigners from the welfare law's scope is constitutional, deciding only the plaintiff's specific claim, and the presiding judge attached a dissenting opinion.

Key Reaction Themes

  • "Legal status and going home come first" (the largest share) — Most comments dismissed the claims outright on the grounds of missing residency status: leave Japan first, a license is beside the point.
  • Rejection of public cost and free-riding — Pushback at funding expensive treatment with taxes, arguing that anyone who wants to help should pay privately or that relatives and the home country should provide support.
  • A small strand of sympathy — A few voices hoped the patient would recover; on other platforms some cited the dissenting opinion's warning about the right to life.

What Japanese Netizens Are Saying

The Supreme Court finalizes rejection of a Ghanaian man's welfare claim

The claim that rejecting welfare on the basis of foreign nationality was unlawful was turned away by the Supreme Court.

ライブドアニュース
ライブドアニュース
@livedoornews
·

【判決】生活保護却下、ガーナ人男性の敗訴確定 news.livedoor.com/article/detail… 最高裁第2小法廷は、来日後に腎不全を患い人工透析治療を受けるガーナ国籍の男性が、外国人であることを理由に生活保護申請を却下されたのは違法だとして、処分取り消しなどを求めた訴訟で、男性の上告を退ける決定をした。

news.livedoor.comガーナ人男性の敗訴確定　生活保護却下、反対意見も最高裁判所＝東京都千代田区最高裁第2小法廷（三浦守裁判長）は、来日後に腎不全を患い人工透析治療を受けるガーナ国籍の男性（36）が、外国人であることを理由に生活保護申請を却下されたのは違法だとして、千葉
Reply
Read 1.3K replies

Comments:

  • "If the people complaining just paid for it themselves, that'd be the end of it."
  • "I hope he pulls through."
  • "When Japanese go to the US for treatment they bring plenty of money for the bills, so if you want treatment in another country, bring the money or go home."
  • "Where's the money for this lawsuit even coming from?"
  • "Japan has no duty to support foreigners. Get support from your own country."
  • "He's wearing nice clothes—hardly looks like someone who needs welfare. Saying he wants to stay in Japan because he can't get dialysis... get support back home. He can stay, but he could just get money from his relatives and the Ghanaian embassy for dialysis, or wouldn't a hospital in Ghana be cheaper? Stop leaning on Japan!"
  • "Let the activist support groups take care of him."
  • "If he has a brother, his brother can support him."
  • "Wouldn't these people hate it if a Japanese went to Ghana and demanded free special treatment and luxuries?"

Thirteen foreigners without residency status sue Saitama over license renewals

Foreigners on provisional release without residency status sued, calling the refusal to renew their driver's licenses unlawful.

弁護士ドットコムニュース
弁護士ドットコムニュース
@bengo4topics
·

在留資格がないことを理由に運転免許証の更新を拒まれたのは違法だとして、埼玉県内に住む「仮放免」の外国籍の男女13人が9月11日、さいたま地裁に提訴しました。 bengo4.com/c_1017/n_20915/ Show more

www.bengo4.com「在留カードがないと免許更新できない」は違法か　仮放免の外国人13人が埼玉県を提訴 - 弁護士ドットコムニュース在留資格がないことを理由に運転免許証の更新を拒まれたのは違法だとして、埼玉県内に住む外国籍の男女13人が9月11日、埼玉県に対し、更新に必要な適性検査と講習の実施などを求める訴訟をさいたま地裁に起こした...
Reply
Read 4 replies

Sources: Bengo4.com, 2ch

Comments:

  • "If you're not here legally, you don't need a license."
  • "If you have no residency status, leaving Japan comes first."
  • "And yet it's more lenient than it is for Japanese."
  • "No residency status = unlawful residence, so the license should be void."
  • "Huh? Residency status comes before a license. Makes no sense."
  • "Just amend the law so you can't get a license without residency status."
  • "The Saitama District Court's good sense is on the line here."
  • "I don't know the details, but shouldn't people without residency status have to leave?"
  • "Instead of asking someone to sort it out, aim to stay here legally."